New Maruti Dzire CNG vs Tata Tigor CNG – Which One To Buy?

Maruti Dzire and Tata Tigor are direct rivals and offered in petrol and CNG guises

In this post, I am comparing the new Maruti Dzire CNG and Tata Tigor CNG in terms of specs, prices, features, design, safety and more. The aim is to let you know the best option for you. Dzire is the highest-selling sedan in India ever. It has been on sale since 2008. Even after 16 years of existence, it is currently at an all-time high demand. We have it in its 4th-generation version at the moment. This time around, Maruti Suzuki offered useful safety amenities to the latest Dzire which resulted in it being the first Maruti Suzuki car to get a full 5-star safety rating at the Global NCAP. On the other hand, Tata Tigor is also a popular product in this category. It boasts a decent 4-star safety rating at the Global NCAP (old protocols). Let us compare the two thoroughly.

Maruti Dzire CNG vs Tata Tigor CNG – Price

Let us commence with arguably the most important criterion for buying a new car for most customers in India, the price. The Maruti Dzire CNG is available in two variants – VXi and ZXi with prices ranging from Rs 8.74 lakh to Rs 9.84 lakh, ex-showroom. On the other hand, the Tata Tigor CNG is offered in 5 variants including an AMT gearbox. These start at Rs 7.60 lakh and go all the way up to Rs 9.40 lakh, ex-showroom. Hence, the Tigor has the price advantage, as well as the convenience of an automated transmission.

Maruti Dzire CNG vs Tata Tigor CNG – Specs and Mileage

Then we compare these two compact sedans in terms of the powertrains and transmissions. The new Maruti Dzire borrows an engine and gearbox from the latest Swift. Hence, it gets a new 1.2-litre 3-cylinder Z12E petrol + CNG engine which belts out a decent 70 PS and 102 Nm of peak power and torque. There is a sole 5-speed manual transmission with this powertrain. Interestingly for the buyers, the Dzire offers a mileage of a massive 33.73 km/kg. That is the highest in the segment. This is the single biggest reason for the incredible demand for Maruti Suzuki products in India.

On the other hand, the Tata Tigor CNG comes with a 1.2-litre 3-cylinder naturally aspirated petrol + CNG engine which is good for 73 PS and 95 Nm of maximum power and torque, respectively. It is slightly more powerful than the Dzire but has lower torque. However, what sets the Tigor CNG apart from the Dzire is the option of choosing between either a 5-speed manual or an AMT gearbox. This makes it one of the few CNG cars to come with automatic gearbox options in the country. It has a healthy edge over its rivals. Even the mileage figures are competitive at 28.06 km/kg. Hence, the fight is neck to neck with the addition of an AMT gearbox with the Tigor CNG.

Maruti Dzire CNG vs Tata Tigor CNG – Features and Safety

Let us now jump into the latest tech, connectivity, convenience and safety amenities on offer on both these cars. We know that modern car buyers want the absolute latest bells and whistles in their vehicles. That is why carmakers remain focused in this regard and equip their products will all sorts of gadgets and gizmos. The 5-star Global NCAP safety-rated Maruti Dzire comes with tons of these including:

• 7-inch Infotainment Display with SmartPlay Pro
• Onboard Voice Assistant via “Hi Suzuki”
• Over-the-Air (OTA) System Upgrades Using Smartphones
• Wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto
• Auto AC
• Rear AC Vents
• Wireless Charger
• 60:40 Split Rear Seat
• Rear USB Ports
• Rear Wiper & Washer
• Adjustable Rear Seat Headrests
• 6-Speaker Audio System
• Luggage Room Lamp
• Electronic Stability Control
• 6 Airbags
• Hill Hold Assist
• ABS with EBD
• Electrically Foldable and Adjustable ORVMs
• ISOFIX Child Seat Mounts
• Engine Push Start/Stop Button w/ Smart Key
• Alexa Skill Connectivity
• Smartwatch Connectivity
• Rear USB Ports
• Steering-Mounted Audio Control

On the other hand, even the Tata Tigor CNG possesses loads of tech and connectivity features. However, I must mention that it has been due for a facelift for a long time. Hence, the list of convenience functionalities is not as expansive as the Dzire. Still, the main highlights are:

• 7-inch Touchscreen Infotainment System by Harman
• Android Auto and Apple CarPlay
• Push-button Start/stop
• Automatic AC
• Electrically Adjustable and Foldable ORVMs
• Driver Seat Height Adjustment
• Rain-sensing Wipers
• Cooled Glove Box
• Steering-mounted Audio Controls
• Fully Digital Instrument Cluster
• Premium Leatherette Seats
• Leather-wrapped Wrapped Steering Wheel
• 8-speaker Audio System
• Rear Defogger
• ConnectNext App Suite
• Digital Controls for Automatic Climate Control
• 2 Airbags
• ABS with EBD & Corner Stability Control
• ISOFIX Child Seat Anchorages
• Seat Belt Reminder (All Seats
• Seat Belt with Pretensioners & Load Limiters
• 3-Point ELR Seat Belts (All Seats)
• Tyre Pressure Monitoring System
• Rear Parking Assist Camera

Maruti Dzire CNG vs Tata Tigor CNG – Design and Dimensions

Let us now move on to discuss how these two compact sedans look. The new Dzire bears a total departure from the last-gen model. It now comes with a fresh front fascia containing a sleek rectangular LED headlamp cluster with integrated LED DRLs, a piano black panel between them, a massive black grille, and a sporty bumper with fog lamps on the extreme edges. That lends it a unique appearance. Apart from that, the side section contains dual-tone 15-inch stylish alloy wheels and a chrome belt underneath the window frames. At the rear, there are many new amenities including a shark fin antenna and arrow-shaped LED taillamps which are connected via a thick chrome slab and a rugged bumper. All in all, this has to be the most striking Maruti Dzire ever.

On the other hand, the Tata Tigor CNG carries the familiar look which we have been witnessing for a few years now. At the front, there is a sleek front grille with tri-arrow insignia and a black strip running at the end of the bonnet. We see the same pattern on the Tiago hatchback from which the Tigor has been created. The headlamps are neatly merged into the sides of the grille and the large fog lamp housing is located on the sporty bumper down below. Moving down the sides highlights stylish alloy wheels, a thick chrome belt under the window frames and a slightly sloping roofline. Completing the external appearance is the rear profile with a shark fin antenna, a boot lid-mounted spoiler, a sleek panel connecting the taillamps and a rugged bumper. Even though appearances are subjective, I would pick the Dzire due to its fresh design.

My View

Choosing between these two compelling compact sedans can be quite tricky. However, I feel it really depends on your personal preference. If you want the latest vehicle with a modern cabin and tech amenities, going for the new Maruti Dzire CNG makes a lot of sense. It is also the safest sedan in the category. On the other hand, if you want a relatively more affordable vehicle and want an automatic transmission, the Tata Tigor CNG will fit the bill. In any case, you can’t go wrong with either of these options.

Also Read: First Real-Life Accident of New Maruti Dzire, See Results