New 2024 Nissan Magnite vs Tata Punch Comparison – What to Buy?

The new Nissan Magnite comes with the same starting price despite having tons of more safety amenities

In this post, I shall compare the new 2024 Nissan Magnite and Tata Punch in terms of specs, features, price, design and safety. Both these have a huge price overlap which makes them ideal candidates for a whole bunch of potential customers. The Magnite has recently received a facelift. Now it is even more feature-laden and bears slight alterations to the exterior and interior. However, the affordability factor is still its major attraction. On the other hand, the Tata Punch is an enticing vehicle which has been doing exceedingly well on the sales charts since its inception. Therefore, this comparison is going to be quite intriguing. Without any further ado, let us delve into this.

New 2024 Nissan Magnite vs Tata Punch – Price

India is a price-conscious market which is why the retail sticker of a car plays a crucial role in deciding its success. The new 2024 Nissan Magnite ranges between Rs 5.99 lakh and Rs 11.50 lakh, ex-showroom. These are very attractive prices for a vehicle of this size. On the other hand, the Tata Punch retails between Rs 6.13 lakh and Rs 10.15 lakh, ex-showroom. Hence, in the base trim, the new Magnite has an edge, whereas on the high trims, the Punch is more favourable.

Also Read: New 2024 Nissan Magnite vs Maruti Fronx – Which One To Buy?

New 2024 Nissan Magnite vs Tata Punch – Specs and Mileage

This is the major point of differentiation between these two compelling propositions. The new Nissan Magnite retains the powertrain options from the outgoing model. Hence, we see a 1.0-litre 3-cylinder petrol engine with and without a turbocharger. In the naturally aspirated guise, this mill churns out a familiar 71 hp and 96 Nm, while in the turbo variant, the power and torque outputs are 99 hp and 152 Nm (160 Nm with CVT), respectively. Performing the transmission duties is either a 5-speed manual, and an AMT or CVT automatic gearbox option. Hence, all sorts of customers can opt for the version that suits their needs the most. Finally, the official mileage figures are 20 km/l for the manual and 17.4 km/l for the CVT automatic.

On the other hand, the Tata Punch is available in a single 1.2-litre 3-cylinder petrol engine version with the option of going for the bi-fuel (Petrol + CNG) version. The power ranges from 73 PS / 103 Nm (CNG) to 88 PS / 115 Nm (petrol) of peak power and torque. With the CNG, buyers get a sole 5-speed manual gearbox, while in a regular petrol avatar, there is a 5-speed manual and an AMT gearbox to select between. The mileage figures for the AMT, and MT in petrol trims are 20.09 km/l and 18.8 km/l, respectively. This number shoots up to an impressive 26.99 km/kg with the CNG powertrain.

New 2024 Nissan Magnite vs Tata Punch – Features

Modern-day customers look for the absolutely top tech, convenience, connectivity and safety amenities in their automobiles. That has become a trend. That is the reason why car marques equip their vehicles with loads of gadgets and gizmos. That is necessary to woo the new-age car buyers. Thankfully, both these cars offer great amenities to pamper the occupants. Let us start with what the new Magnite has to offer:

• 7-inch Configurable TFT Driver Display
• 8-inch Floating Touchscreen Infotainment Display
• Leatherette Interior Components including Steering, Door Panel, Centre Console
• Heat Insulation Coating on Seats to Keep Them Cool Even in Direct Sunlight
• 4 Ambient Lighting Colours
• Front Armrest with Storage
• Cooled Glovebox
• 336-litre Boot Space
• Rear Cup Holder Inside and Smartphone Holder Armrest
• Cluster Ionizer (PM2.5 Air Purifier)
• Wireless Android Auto and Apple CarPlay
• Around View Monitor
• Wireless Phone Charger
• New I-Key with Tons of Remote Functions
• Auto Dim Frameless IRVM (biggest in the segment)
• 40+ Standard Safety Features (55 Features in the Top Trim)
• 6-Speaker 3D Surround System by ARKAMYS
• Type-C USB
• 8-inch Touchscreen Infotainment Display
• 6 Airbags
• 3 Point Seatbelts
• Seatbelt Reminder for All Seats
• ISOFIX Child Seat Mounts
• High-Speed Alert System
• Emergency Stop Signal (ESS)
• Reinforced Body Structure

On the other hand, even the Tata Punch boasts loads of new-age amenities to pamper the customers. The main highlights include:

• 10.25-inch Infotainment System by Harman
• 10.25-inch Digital Instrument Cluster
• iRA Connected Car Tech
• Leatherette Ventilated Seats
• Panoramic Sunroof
• Air Purifier
• Cooled Glovebox
• Wireless Phone Charging
• Leather-Wrapped Steering Wheel
• Wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto
• Tyre Pressure Monitoring System
• Automatic Climate Control
• Voice Commands
• Height Adjustable Front Seats
• 8-Speaker Audio System
• 360-degree Camera
• 6 Airbags
• Blind View Monitor
• Front Parking Sensors
• Auto-Dimming IRVM
• Steering Mounted Controls
• Electrically Adjustable ORVMs

Also Read: New 2024 Nissan Magnite vs Maruti Brezza – What To Buy?

Design and Dimensions

The design and appearance of the two SUVs are quite distinct. On one hand, we have the new Nissan Magnite which is not a long departure from the outgoing model. At the front, a large grille area with sleek chrome elements flanking it. Apart from that, the sleek LED headlamp cluster with integrated LED DRLs lend a modern appearance. I particularly like the skid plate section which elevates the rugged characteristics of the SUV. On the sides is where one gets to witness the elegant alloy wheels with black side pillars, sturdy side body claddings, stylish 16-inch alloy wheels, and a black roof. At the rear, there are clear-lens M-shaped signature LED taillamps and a sporty bumper.

On the other hand, the Tata Punch also boasts a modern design philosophy. The front fascia gets a sleek LED DRLs section on the bonnet connected by a chrome belt. The main headlamp cluster is situated on the extreme edges of the bumper. Also, I like the black bumper which imposes that sporty presence. On the edges, you will find compact fog lamps. The side section contains the squarish wheel arches and elegant alloy wheels. Also, the black side pillars and faux roof rails elevate its SUV-ish demeanour. At the rear, the compact LED taillamps, a roof-mounted spoiler and a solid bumper complete the overall look. All in all, both these SUVs have their appeal.

My View

It is not easy to choose between these two compelling propositions. However, there will be distinction customers for these. For instance, if you want to experiment with a relatively new brand and a slightly bigger SUV, going for the new 2024 Nissan Magnite makes a lot of sense. It does most things right and is a great product with the latest tech and convenience amenities, as well as a potent turbo petrol engine. On the other hand, if you want to go with an established brand and an imposing little SUV which boasts a full 5-star safety rating at the NCAP, then you should buy the Tata Punch. I would encourage our readers to experience these cars in the flesh at your nearest showrooms to make up your minds.

Also Read: New Nissan Magnite vs Old Base Model Comparison